The index · Strategy No. 04 · Ranked #1 of 1

“Sell in May and go away.”

Sit out May through October, every single year. Wall Street’s favorite saying.

FAILS

trailed holding by 3.7% a year

Annual return
6.8%
Holding: 10.5%
Worst drop
−34.9%
Holding: −55.2%
Sharpe ratio
0.41
Holding: 0.53
$10,000 became
$42,053
Holding: $88,332
Time in market
49%
Holding: 100%
Trades
22
68% winners

Watch it

The 60-second version Watch on YouTube ↗
The full breakdown Watch on YouTube ↗
Growth of $10,000 · 2005-01-03 to 2026-11-19
Sell in May Just holding SPY

The exact rules

  • Buy when the month is outside May–Oct.
  • Sell when the month is in May–Oct.
  • Signals on the close, filled at the next open with 0.02% slippage. All in, no leverage. Dividends reinvested, idle cash earns T-bill interest.

same house rules as every other strategy

Remix this test in the lab →

Did it survive new data?

Years from 2023 on are held back from the verdict. If an edge is real, it should still show up there.

PeriodStrategyHoldingWorst dropSharpe
2005–2022 (tested) 6.2% 8.7% −34.9% 0.41 vs 0.46
2023–now (held out) 9.5% 19.1% −18.8% 0.43 vs 0.94

Is it a fluke of one setting?

Sharpe ratio at nearby settings, whole period. Yellow beats holding SPY (0.53), red trails it. The boxed cell is the famous version. 0 of 16 settings beat holding.

Across: Sell at start of month · Down: Buy back at start of month

Sharpe ratio by Sell at start of month and Buy back at start of month
4567
9 0.270.390.420.42
10 0.310.430.470.46
11 0.280.410.450.45
12 0.140.300.350.34

Recent trades

BoughtSoldBuy priceSell priceReturn
2025-11-03 2026-05-01 $685.81 $721.11 5.15%
2024-11-01 2025-05-01 $571.43 $560.26 −1.96%
2023-11-01 2024-05-01 $419.28 $501.28 19.56%
2022-11-01 2023-05-01 $390.22 $415.39 6.45%
2021-11-01 2022-05-02 $460.39 $411.99 −10.51%
2020-11-02 2021-05-03 $330.27 $419.35 26.97%
2019-11-01 2020-05-01 $304.98 $285.25 −6.47%
2018-11-01 2019-05-01 $271.65 $294.66 8.47%
2017-11-01 2018-05-01 $258.09 $263.82 2.22%
2016-11-01 2017-05-01 $212.97 $238.63 12.05%

Trade returns are price only; dividends and cash interest show up in the totals above. Open positions aren't shown.

Price data: Yahoo Finance (fetched 2026-11-20), T-bill rates: FRED DTB3. Verdict suggested by the numbers, pending monthly review. Simulated results for education only; not investment advice. Past performance doesn't predict future results.

One strategy, tested, every Sunday.
(the honest result, good or bad)