Trading strategies.
Tested.
Ranked.

20 yrs of SPY,
dividends & all

Every famous trading rule, put through one honest standard and ranked against simply holding SPY.

No spam, unsubscribe any time. Privacy

Strategy of the week · No. 04

“Sell in May and go away.”

Sit out May through October, every single year. Wall Street’s favorite saying. Tested on every year since 2005.

The strategy
6.8%
Just holding
10.5%
FAILS 2005 2026 just holding sell in may
Growth of $10,000, SPY, dividends reinvested, log scale

The index

Ranked by annual return over buy and hold.
# Strategy Return Worst drop vs holding Verdict
1 Sell in May this week’s test!
Buy SPY when the month is outside May–Oct. Sell when the month is in May–Oct.
6.8% −34.9%
−3.7
FAILS
Buy and hold SPY: 10.5% a year, −55.2% worst drop, 2005-01-03 to 2026-11-19. Simulated, not investment advice. Price data: Yahoo Finance

Up next

One a week, each with a video. Results go up the day the video does.
  1. Buy the dip
  2. The golden cross
  3. Bollinger band bounce
  4. Santa Claus rally
  5. MACD crossover
  6. Sell after a 10% drop
  7. Missing the 10 best days
  8. Dollar-cost averaging

Want one tested sooner? Tell me in the comments on the latest video.

One standard.
Every strategy.

no cherry-picking — the rules are the same for everyone

The full method →
Market
SPY only, daily bars, 2005 to today
Starting money
$10,000, all in, no leverage
Timing
Signal on the close, fill at the next open
Costs
0.02% slippage on every fill
Dividends
Reinvested, for the strategy and for holding
Idle cash
Earns the 3-month T-bill rate while out of the market
Benchmark
Every result next to just holding SPY
Held-out years
2023 onward kept back to check the edge survives
One strategy, tested, every Sunday.
(the honest result, good or bad)