Trading strategies.
Tested.
Ranked.
20 yrs of SPY,
dividends & all
dividends & all
Every famous trading rule, put through one honest standard and ranked against simply holding SPY.
COMING SOON
No spam, unsubscribe any time. Privacy
Up next
One a week, each with a video. Verdicts go up the day the video does.
| # | Strategy | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 01 | Buy the dip first up! Buy SPY after a sharp short-term drop, but only while the long-term trend is up. Sell on the bounce. | TESTING… |
| 02 | The golden cross Own SPY while its 50-day average is above its 200-day average, sit in cash when it’s below. | TESTING… |
| 03 | Bollinger band bounce Buy when price closes below the lower Bollinger Band, sell when it gets back to the middle. | TESTING… |
| 04 | Santa Claus rally Own SPY only for the last five trading days of December and the first two of January. | TESTING… |
| 05 | MACD crossover Own SPY while the MACD line is above its signal line, the textbook settings. | TESTING… |
| 06 | Sell after a 10% drop Sell once SPY is 10% below its one-year high. Buy back when it recovers to within 5% of the high. | TESTING… |
| 07 | Missing the 10 best days What if you’d held SPY the whole time but been out of the market on its 10 best days? Picked with hindsight, to see what the saying is really worth. | TESTING… |
| 08 | Dollar-cost averaging Instead of investing the $10,000 on day one, put it in over 12 months, an equal slice each month, with the rest earning T-bill interest while it waits. | TESTING… |
| 09 | The 10-month average Meb Faber’s rule: on the last trading day of each month, own SPY if it’s above its 10-month average, otherwise sit in cash. | TESTING… |
| 10 | Avoid September Sit out every September, the month with the worst reputation. Own SPY the other eleven. | TESTING… |
| 11 | The 200-day line Own SPY while it’s above its 200-day average, sit in cash while it’s below. | TESTING… |
| 12 | The fast cross The golden cross, sped up: own SPY while its 20-day average is above its 50-day. | TESTING… |
| 13 | Three red days Buy SPY after it closes down three days in a row, then sell five trading days later. | TESTING… |
| 14 | Buy the 5% dip Buy once SPY is 5% below its one-year high. Sell when it’s back within 1% of the high. | TESTING… |
| 15 | Get out of the bear Sell once SPY is 20% below its one-year high. Buy back when it recovers to within 5% of the high. | TESTING… |
| 16 | Only buy at the highs The opposite of the advice: buy only within 1% of SPY’s three-year high, sell after a 5% drop from it. | TESTING… |
| 17 | The 10% stop loss Own SPY while it’s above its 50-day average, but sell any trade that falls 10%. | TESTING… |
| 18 | The breakout The old turtle-trader rule: buy a new 20-day high, sell a new 10-day low. | TESTING… |
| 19 | Williams %R Buy when Williams %R(10) drops below -80, sell when it climbs above -20. | TESTING… |
| 20 | Buy the gap down When SPY opens at least 1% below yesterday’s close, buy the next open and sell a day later. | TESTING… |
| 21 | Close near the low Buy when SPY closes in the bottom 20% of its day’s range, sell when it closes in the top 20%. | TESTING… |
| 22 | Calm markets only Own SPY only while its 20-day volatility is below its 100-day average. | TESTING… |
One standard.
Every strategy.
no cherry-picking — the rules are the same for everyone
The full method →- Market
- SPY only, daily bars, 2005 to today
- Starting money
- $10,000, all in, no leverage
- Timing
- Signal on the close, fill at the next open
- Costs
- 0.02% slippage on every fill
- Dividends
- Reinvested, for the strategy and for holding
- Idle cash
- Earns the 3-month T-bill rate while out of the market
- Benchmark
- Every result next to just holding SPY
- Held-out years
- 2023 onward kept back to check the edge survives
One strategy, tested, every Sunday.
(the honest result, good or bad)